{
  "updated_on": "2026-10-16",
  "status": "repairing_after_partial_recheck",
  "scope": "Initial full61-case review plus repaired partial rechecks; a score applies only to its named frozen snapshot.",
  "axes": {
    "source_fidelity": 35,
    "demonstration": 35,
    "visual_per_case": 18,
    "global_UI": 12
  },
  "reviews": [
    {
      "reviewer": "Kimi K3",
      "case_count": 61,
      "case_score_max": 88,
      "mean_case_score": 83.2131,
      "global_UI_score": null,
      "global_UI_max": 12,
      "all_cases_full_marks": false
    },
    {
      "reviewer": "Claude Opus 5.5",
      "case_count": 61,
      "case_score_max": 88,
      "mean_case_score": 62.7705,
      "global_UI_score": null,
      "global_UI_max": 12,
      "all_cases_full_marks": false
    }
  ],
  "score_of_current_repaired_site": null,
  "completed_100_of_100": false,
  "next_step": "Continue repairing original-source, visual and UI findings; continue exact Kimi K3 on fresh snapshots and resume Opus5.5 after its quota reset. Kimi shared UI12 passed; full61 and repaired UI Opus pass remain unconfirmed.",
  "partial_recheck": {
    "frozen_cases": 54,
    "kimi_completed_cases": 41,
    "kimi_score_min": 80,
    "kimi_score_max": 88,
    "case_score_max": 88,
    "opus_completed_cases": 47,
    "global_UI_score": null,
    "batches": [
      {
        "snapshot_id": "round2-kimi-01-20261015T132212Z",
        "manifest_sha256": "7cbf71f1640a9482835df08ad69a0b0858081de89e4acda1d7f79f516edcade5",
        "reviewer": "Kimi K3",
        "cases": [
          {
            "case_id": "mck-native-showcase",
            "score": 87,
            "max": 88
          },
          {
            "case_id": "sci-diagram-reconstruction",
            "score": 87,
            "max": 88
          },
          {
            "case_id": "html-editable-showcase",
            "score": 88,
            "max": 88
          },
          {
            "case_id": "hand-drawn-showcase",
            "score": 87,
            "max": 88
          },
          {
            "case_id": "pptwise-showcase",
            "score": 87,
            "max": 88
          },
          {
            "case_id": "aham-showcase",
            "score": 87,
            "max": 88
          }
        ],
        "mean_case_score": 87.17,
        "global_UI_score": null,
        "validation": "Exact reviewer CLI/model and frozen manifest identity; arithmetic checked. Scores apply only to this immutable snapshot."
      },
      {
        "snapshot_id": "round2-kimi-04-20261015T132308Z",
        "manifest_sha256": "fd08ad9fe8ebd0dea153e5afcc925418c81d12ea720c4e341453685f1f920da9",
        "reviewer": "Kimi K3",
        "cases": [
          {
            "case_id": "sebastian-203",
            "score": 88,
            "max": 88
          },
          {
            "case_id": "sebastian-193",
            "score": 87,
            "max": 88
          },
          {
            "case_id": "learndeck-showcase",
            "score": 87,
            "max": 88
          },
          {
            "case_id": "cyberppt",
            "score": 88,
            "max": 88
          },
          {
            "case_id": "cafe-pptx",
            "score": 88,
            "max": 88
          },
          {
            "case_id": "japanese-corporate",
            "score": 88,
            "max": 88
          },
          {
            "case_id": "presentation-delivery",
            "score": 86,
            "max": 88
          }
        ],
        "mean_case_score": 87.43,
        "global_UI_score": null,
        "validation": "Exact reviewer CLI/model and frozen manifest identity; arithmetic checked. Scores apply only to this immutable snapshot."
      },
      {
        "snapshot_id": "round2-kimi-08-20261015T132311Z",
        "manifest_sha256": "2053eb48c43b149cb8b80e8ea38fbe9286419a6fb0ad212c9b5d4e2015d6941d",
        "reviewer": "Kimi K3",
        "cases": [
          {
            "case_id": "and-scene-showcase",
            "score": 86,
            "max": 88
          },
          {
            "case_id": "sebastian-178",
            "score": 87,
            "max": 88
          },
          {
            "case_id": "sebastian-173",
            "score": 87,
            "max": 88
          },
          {
            "case_id": "port-town",
            "score": 88,
            "max": 88
          },
          {
            "case_id": "html-scrolline",
            "score": 88,
            "max": 88
          },
          {
            "case_id": "react-slide-deck",
            "score": 88,
            "max": 88
          },
          {
            "case_id": "qiaomu-bento",
            "score": 88,
            "max": 88
          }
        ],
        "mean_case_score": 87.43,
        "global_UI_score": null,
        "validation": "Exact reviewer CLI/model and frozen manifest identity; arithmetic checked. Scores apply only to this immutable snapshot."
      },
      {
        "snapshot_id": "round2-kimi-09-20261015T140610Z",
        "manifest_sha256": "273d3f495571837d767a303ff24166198422f596ae570cf3fbd600f5d8d916d6",
        "reviewer": "Kimi K3",
        "cases": [
          {
            "case_id": "seaslides",
            "score": 87,
            "max": 88
          },
          {
            "case_id": "minorun-marp",
            "score": 88,
            "max": 88
          },
          {
            "case_id": "ppt-design-system",
            "score": 88,
            "max": 88
          },
          {
            "case_id": "business-carousel",
            "score": 88,
            "max": 88
          },
          {
            "case_id": "magic-slide",
            "score": 87,
            "max": 88
          },
          {
            "case_id": "revealjs-skill",
            "score": 88,
            "max": 88
          },
          {
            "case_id": "aws-html-showcase",
            "score": 88,
            "max": 88
          }
        ],
        "mean_case_score": 87.71,
        "global_UI_score": null,
        "validation": "Exact reviewer CLI/model and frozen manifest identity; arithmetic checked. Scores apply only to this immutable snapshot."
      },
      {
        "snapshot_id": "round3-kimi-01-20261015T142140Z",
        "manifest_sha256": "ab4d26d94ab6fcd203a4eff5e38a7532078cd9e7b32c55d274a30052d1f4a79b",
        "reviewer": "Kimi K3",
        "cases": [
          {
            "case_id": "mck-native-showcase",
            "score": 87,
            "max": 88
          },
          {
            "case_id": "sci-diagram-reconstruction",
            "score": 88,
            "max": 88
          },
          {
            "case_id": "html-editable-showcase",
            "score": 87,
            "max": 88
          },
          {
            "case_id": "hand-drawn-showcase",
            "score": 88,
            "max": 88
          },
          {
            "case_id": "pptwise-showcase",
            "score": 87,
            "max": 88
          },
          {
            "case_id": "aham-showcase",
            "score": 88,
            "max": 88
          }
        ],
        "mean_case_score": 87.5,
        "global_UI_score": null,
        "validation": "Exact reviewer CLI/model and frozen manifest identity; arithmetic checked. Scores apply only to this immutable snapshot."
      },
      {
        "snapshot_id": "round3-kimi-05-20261015T143131Z",
        "manifest_sha256": "7ba931d085108c61d7a3e1cea09e6f228d91217e7611ad828732abdf29987bb7",
        "reviewer": "Kimi K3",
        "cases": [
          {
            "case_id": "pradaslides",
            "score": 87,
            "max": 88
          },
          {
            "case_id": "office-powerpoint-mcp",
            "score": 87,
            "max": 88
          },
          {
            "case_id": "ppt-design-skill",
            "score": 86,
            "max": 88
          },
          {
            "case_id": "hands-on-deck",
            "score": 88,
            "max": 88
          },
          {
            "case_id": "image-to-editable",
            "score": 88,
            "max": 88
          },
          {
            "case_id": "codex-image-ppt",
            "score": 87,
            "max": 88
          },
          {
            "case_id": "slide-maker",
            "score": 84,
            "max": 88
          }
        ],
        "mean_case_score": 86.71,
        "global_UI_score": null,
        "validation": "Exact reviewer CLI/model and frozen manifest identity; arithmetic checked. Scores apply only to this immutable snapshot."
      },
      {
        "snapshot_id": "round3-kimi-03-20261015T150943Z",
        "manifest_sha256": "71f381e1d9655de75630996e1aeb239f81758e2a2b385af09fa3225d2c8a6039",
        "reviewer": "Claude Opus 5.5",
        "cases": [
          {
            "case_id": "sebastian-192",
            "score": 70,
            "max": 88
          },
          {
            "case_id": "ppt-agent-showcase",
            "score": 68,
            "max": 88
          },
          {
            "case_id": "presentation-skill-showcase",
            "score": 63,
            "max": 88
          },
          {
            "case_id": "scene-graph-showcase",
            "score": 62,
            "max": 88
          },
          {
            "case_id": "sebastian-188",
            "score": 69,
            "max": 88
          },
          {
            "case_id": "slidepoise-showcase",
            "score": 70,
            "max": 88
          },
          {
            "case_id": "sebastian-205",
            "score": 71,
            "max": 88
          }
        ],
        "mean_case_score": 67.57,
        "global_UI_score": null,
        "validation": "Exact reviewer CLI/model, immutable payload hashes and arithmetic checked. Scores apply only to this snapshot. Actual successful image Read calls checked, including byte-identical aliases."
      },
      {
        "snapshot_id": "round3-kimi-04-20261015T142141Z",
        "manifest_sha256": "fc0c9d446f74e38993304fadd321c5d4c9d41221b2ed73a5a1692dcfd16444c3",
        "reviewer": "Claude Opus 5.5",
        "cases": [
          {
            "case_id": "sebastian-203",
            "score": 73,
            "max": 88
          },
          {
            "case_id": "sebastian-193",
            "score": 69,
            "max": 88
          },
          {
            "case_id": "learndeck-showcase",
            "score": 71,
            "max": 88
          },
          {
            "case_id": "cyberppt",
            "score": 72,
            "max": 88
          },
          {
            "case_id": "cafe-pptx",
            "score": 70,
            "max": 88
          },
          {
            "case_id": "japanese-corporate",
            "score": 75,
            "max": 88
          },
          {
            "case_id": "presentation-delivery",
            "score": 72,
            "max": 88
          }
        ],
        "mean_case_score": 71.71,
        "global_UI_score": null,
        "validation": "Exact reviewer CLI/model, immutable payload hashes and arithmetic checked. Scores apply only to this snapshot. Older CLI final report retained; image-read tool trace unavailable."
      },
      {
        "snapshot_id": "round3-kimi-05-20261015T143131Z",
        "manifest_sha256": "7ba931d085108c61d7a3e1cea09e6f228d91217e7611ad828732abdf29987bb7",
        "reviewer": "Claude Opus 5.5",
        "cases": [
          {
            "case_id": "slide-maker",
            "score": 65,
            "max": 88
          },
          {
            "case_id": "pradaslides",
            "score": 66,
            "max": 88
          },
          {
            "case_id": "office-powerpoint-mcp",
            "score": 74,
            "max": 88
          },
          {
            "case_id": "ppt-design-skill",
            "score": 71,
            "max": 88
          },
          {
            "case_id": "hands-on-deck",
            "score": 65,
            "max": 88
          },
          {
            "case_id": "image-to-editable",
            "score": 76,
            "max": 88
          },
          {
            "case_id": "codex-image-ppt",
            "score": 71,
            "max": 88
          }
        ],
        "mean_case_score": 69.71,
        "global_UI_score": null,
        "validation": "Exact reviewer CLI/model, immutable payload hashes and arithmetic checked. Scores apply only to this snapshot. Older CLI final report retained; image-read tool trace unavailable."
      },
      {
        "snapshot_id": "round3-kimi-07-20261015T151117Z",
        "manifest_sha256": "79703b9030bd8a76ec9ffa98c73b5bfa235c74ea5f8a19078ef3c74466e3678b",
        "reviewer": "Claude Opus 5.5",
        "cases": [
          {
            "case_id": "design-dna-showcase",
            "score": 71,
            "max": 88
          },
          {
            "case_id": "cogine-templates-showcase",
            "score": 61,
            "max": 88
          },
          {
            "case_id": "keynot-showcase",
            "score": 66,
            "max": 88
          },
          {
            "case_id": "beatdeck-showcase",
            "score": 73,
            "max": 88
          },
          {
            "case_id": "quarto-talks-showcase",
            "score": 71,
            "max": 88
          },
          {
            "case_id": "zhongguose-showcase",
            "score": 65,
            "max": 88
          },
          {
            "case_id": "presentation-forge-showcase",
            "score": 69,
            "max": 88
          }
        ],
        "mean_case_score": 68.0,
        "global_UI_score": null,
        "validation": "Exact reviewer CLI/model, immutable payload hashes and arithmetic checked. Scores apply only to this snapshot. Actual successful image Read calls checked, including byte-identical aliases."
      },
      {
        "snapshot_id": "round3-kimi-08-20261015T142143Z",
        "manifest_sha256": "81c4796e33305833e09d78a39b7a0bf336dd907befefb25c7abb7835740a64af",
        "reviewer": "Claude Opus 5.5",
        "cases": [
          {
            "case_id": "and-scene-showcase",
            "score": 66,
            "max": 88
          },
          {
            "case_id": "sebastian-178",
            "score": 61,
            "max": 88
          },
          {
            "case_id": "sebastian-173",
            "score": 64,
            "max": 88
          },
          {
            "case_id": "port-town",
            "score": 69,
            "max": 88
          },
          {
            "case_id": "html-scrolline",
            "score": 67,
            "max": 88
          },
          {
            "case_id": "react-slide-deck",
            "score": 68,
            "max": 88
          },
          {
            "case_id": "qiaomu-bento",
            "score": 73,
            "max": 88
          }
        ],
        "mean_case_score": 66.86,
        "global_UI_score": null,
        "validation": "Exact reviewer CLI/model, immutable payload hashes and arithmetic checked. Scores apply only to this snapshot. Older CLI final report retained; image-read tool trace unavailable."
      },
      {
        "snapshot_id": "round4-rechecks-01-20261015T154411Z",
        "manifest_sha256": "d13907fa40e455993fe154b22501ce3800a69b58e969f3526fc3573d7c266487",
        "reviewer": "Claude Opus 5.5",
        "cases": [
          {
            "case_id": "mck-native-showcase",
            "score": 68,
            "max": 88
          },
          {
            "case_id": "sci-diagram-reconstruction",
            "score": 70,
            "max": 88
          },
          {
            "case_id": "html-editable-showcase",
            "score": 64,
            "max": 88
          },
          {
            "case_id": "hand-drawn-showcase",
            "score": 64,
            "max": 88
          },
          {
            "case_id": "pptwise-showcase",
            "score": 58,
            "max": 88
          },
          {
            "case_id": "aham-showcase",
            "score": 63,
            "max": 88
          }
        ],
        "mean_case_score": 64.5,
        "global_UI_score": null,
        "validation": "Exact reviewer CLI/model, immutable payload hashes and arithmetic checked. Scores apply only to this snapshot. Actual successful image Read calls checked, including byte-identical aliases."
      },
      {
        "snapshot_id": "round4-rechecks-02-20261015T152653Z",
        "manifest_sha256": "917cf15508fc1c7b82ae3b3ba41969ce71acb2d292b4a09a30eb8d61afebd518",
        "reviewer": "Claude Opus 5.5",
        "cases": [
          {
            "case_id": "agent-slides-showcase",
            "score": 70,
            "max": 88
          },
          {
            "case_id": "beamer-showcase",
            "score": 75,
            "max": 88
          },
          {
            "case_id": "native-math-showcase",
            "score": 77,
            "max": 88
          },
          {
            "case_id": "thesis-defense-showcase",
            "score": 70,
            "max": 88
          },
          {
            "case_id": "sebastian-207",
            "score": 59,
            "max": 88
          },
          {
            "case_id": "sebastian-208",
            "score": 62,
            "max": 88
          }
        ],
        "mean_case_score": 68.83,
        "global_UI_score": null,
        "validation": "Exact reviewer CLI/model, immutable payload hashes and arithmetic checked. Scores apply only to this snapshot. Actual successful image Read calls checked, including byte-identical aliases."
      },
      {
        "snapshot_id": "round4-rechecks-05-20261015T152652Z",
        "manifest_sha256": "e2ebdb53756bcca5dffd649b13f4b520e74b3a7bb663608af242dd0800ade878",
        "reviewer": "Claude Opus 5.5",
        "cases": [
          {
            "case_id": "slide-maker",
            "score": 67,
            "max": 88
          }
        ],
        "mean_case_score": 67.0,
        "global_UI_score": null,
        "validation": "Exact reviewer CLI/model, immutable payload hashes and arithmetic checked. Scores apply only to this snapshot. Actual successful image Read calls checked, including byte-identical aliases."
      },
      {
        "snapshot_id": "round5-rechecks-05-20261015T161726Z",
        "manifest_sha256": "18bf3cbc44151520c272df19f519fafce733bdc0cf67c09b70588a4eedfe3c7f",
        "reviewer": "Kimi K3",
        "cases": [
          {
            "case_id": "slide-maker",
            "score": 80,
            "max": 88
          }
        ],
        "mean_case_score": 80.0,
        "global_UI_score": null,
        "validation": "Exact Kimi K3 CLI execution0; immutable hashes, arithmetic and successful ReadMediaFile image results verified. Applies only to this frozen snapshot."
      },
      {
        "snapshot_id": "round6-rechecks-04-20261015T165310Z",
        "manifest_sha256": "df74ba5a280600c1a709a19c25b2b4586d405d7d27820790b9a49b7d2f7e9d67",
        "reviewer": "Kimi K3",
        "cases": [
          {
            "case_id": "sebastian-193",
            "score": 86,
            "max": 88
          }
        ],
        "mean_case_score": 86.0,
        "global_UI_score": null,
        "validation": "Exact Kimi K3 CLI execution0; immutable hashes, arithmetic and successful ReadMediaFile image results verified. Applies only to this frozen snapshot."
      },
      {
        "snapshot_id": "round6-rechecks-05-20261015T162656Z",
        "manifest_sha256": "faa8c9489c5cf38f39661a725f67c035d8f76646378e83bc9d9c951bf64993c5",
        "reviewer": "Kimi K3",
        "cases": [
          {
            "case_id": "pradaslides",
            "score": 88,
            "max": 88
          },
          {
            "case_id": "office-powerpoint-mcp",
            "score": 88,
            "max": 88
          },
          {
            "case_id": "ppt-design-skill",
            "score": 88,
            "max": 88
          },
          {
            "case_id": "hands-on-deck",
            "score": 88,
            "max": 88
          },
          {
            "case_id": "image-to-editable",
            "score": 88,
            "max": 88
          },
          {
            "case_id": "codex-image-ppt",
            "score": 83,
            "max": 88
          }
        ],
        "mean_case_score": 87.17,
        "global_UI_score": null,
        "validation": "Exact Kimi K3 CLI execution0; immutable hashes, arithmetic and successful ReadMediaFile image results verified. Applies only to this frozen snapshot."
      },
      {
        "snapshot_id": "round7-rechecks-01-20261015T173002Z",
        "manifest_sha256": "47d5320b4fc3abe602ecaeb5e5e3892048ab53cd511c3072875a36da7619c942",
        "reviewer": "Kimi K3",
        "cases": [
          {
            "case_id": "mck-native-showcase",
            "score": 88,
            "max": 88
          },
          {
            "case_id": "pptwise-showcase",
            "score": 88,
            "max": 88
          },
          {
            "case_id": "aham-showcase",
            "score": 88,
            "max": 88
          }
        ],
        "mean_case_score": 88.0,
        "global_UI_score": null,
        "validation": "Exact Kimi K3 CLI execution0; immutable hashes, arithmetic and successful ReadMediaFile image results verified. Applies only to this frozen snapshot."
      },
      {
        "snapshot_id": "round7-rechecks-04-20261015T172523Z",
        "manifest_sha256": "40bcface76441e6c9c41fa02d346e4a2bacd8a91e93e6a72c07c69d2bb17a6d2",
        "reviewer": "Kimi K3",
        "cases": [
          {
            "case_id": "sebastian-193",
            "score": 88,
            "max": 88
          },
          {
            "case_id": "japanese-corporate",
            "score": 88,
            "max": 88
          }
        ],
        "mean_case_score": 88.0,
        "global_UI_score": null,
        "validation": "Exact Kimi K3 CLI execution0; immutable hashes, arithmetic and successful ReadMediaFile image results verified. Applies only to this frozen snapshot."
      },
      {
        "snapshot_id": "round7-rechecks-05-20261015T171434Z",
        "manifest_sha256": "f72527745b8eeef43f597d541bb27d093f5652e561333ee61f373ceb29e8c736",
        "reviewer": "Kimi K3",
        "cases": [
          {
            "case_id": "codex-image-ppt",
            "score": 81,
            "max": 88
          }
        ],
        "mean_case_score": 81.0,
        "global_UI_score": null,
        "validation": "Exact Kimi K3 CLI execution0; immutable hashes, arithmetic and successful ReadMediaFile image results verified. Applies only to this frozen snapshot."
      },
      {
        "snapshot_id": "round7-rechecks-07-20261015T170515Z",
        "manifest_sha256": "691f6f5a3870564dfa98b5ec983d049a6808e597b60b64db782fe82aec50872f",
        "reviewer": "Kimi K3",
        "cases": [
          {
            "case_id": "design-dna-showcase",
            "score": 88,
            "max": 88
          },
          {
            "case_id": "cogine-templates-showcase",
            "score": 88,
            "max": 88
          },
          {
            "case_id": "keynot-showcase",
            "score": 88,
            "max": 88
          },
          {
            "case_id": "beatdeck-showcase",
            "score": 88,
            "max": 88
          },
          {
            "case_id": "quarto-talks-showcase",
            "score": 88,
            "max": 88
          },
          {
            "case_id": "zhongguose-showcase",
            "score": 88,
            "max": 88
          },
          {
            "case_id": "presentation-forge-showcase",
            "score": 88,
            "max": 88
          }
        ],
        "mean_case_score": 88.0,
        "global_UI_score": null,
        "validation": "Exact Kimi K3 CLI execution0; immutable hashes, arithmetic and successful ReadMediaFile image results verified. Applies only to this frozen snapshot."
      }
    ],
    "opus_score_min": 58,
    "opus_score_max": 77
  },
  "reviewer_availability": {
    "Kimi K3": {
      "status": "review_resumed",
      "observed_at_utc": "2026-10-15T16:38:55Z",
      "reset_at": null
    },
    "Claude Opus 5.5": {
      "status": "session_usage_limit",
      "observed_at_utc": "2026-10-15T16:05:43Z",
      "reset_at": "2026-10-16T04:50:00+09:00"
    }
  },
  "interrupted_rechecks": [
    {
      "snapshot_id": "round4-rechecks-08-20261015T155759Z",
      "reviewer": "Claude Opus 5.5",
      "exit_code": 1,
      "score_counted": false,
      "reason": "CLI session limit reached before successful completion."
    },
    {
      "snapshot_id": "round4-rechecks-06-20261015T155824Z",
      "reviewer": "Claude Opus 5.5",
      "exit_code": 1,
      "score_counted": false,
      "reason": "CLI session limit reached before successful completion."
    }
  ],
  "global_UI_rechecks": [
    {
      "reviewer": "Claude Opus 5.5",
      "snapshot_id": "ui-round1-20261015T155241Z",
      "manifest_sha256": "dcaecc16bd3a19dd7ea35cb744f0a06fb6e64bdc3ffbdc616c4e52c61ace6a76",
      "score": 8,
      "max": 12,
      "skill_first": 5,
      "responsive_and_reuse": 3,
      "actual_images_checked": 16,
      "applies_to_current_repaired_site": false
    },
    {
      "reviewer": "Kimi K3",
      "snapshot_id": "ui-round2-20261015T163223Z",
      "manifest_sha256": "a85f426db72626d0ceea0efc75f6b6132cc55eebc9de4ec584fdcae9b43297c3",
      "score": 12,
      "max": 12,
      "skill_first": 8,
      "responsive_and_reuse": 4,
      "actual_images_checked": 16,
      "ui_revision": "after_ui_repairs",
      "applies_to_current_repaired_site": false,
      "scope": "Shared UI only. Individual-case88 and complete61 are separate."
    }
  ]
}